Goodreads Choice Awards 2026: The Drama, the Indie Authors, and Why I Apparently Only Vote for Women

Goodreads Choice Awards 2026: The Drama, the Indie Authors, and Why I Apparently Only Vote for Women
Fifteen categories, two rounds of voting, literary controversies, bestselling authors competing against themselves, and one James Patterson who somehow managed to sneak onto my ballot.

Dear Rebels, it is that wonderful time of the year when bookworms across the world temporarily abandon their reading schedules to argue about which books deserve to be crowned the best of the year. The Goodreads Choice Awards are officially underway, I’ve submitted my votes, and naturally, I’ve been digging around the internet for a little literary gossip.
Whilst reviewing my choices, however, I discovered something rather amusing about myself. Apparently, I vote for women. In every single bloody category.
Technically, James Patterson managed to sneak onto my ballot alongside Viola Davis, but in my head, Viola wrote the entire book herself. Sorry, James. Nothing personal.
Goodreads Choice Awards 2026: Everything You Need to Know
Now in their eighteenth edition, the Goodreads Choice Awards give readers the opportunity to decide which books deserve recognition across fifteen literary categories. This year’s opening round features twenty nominations per category, making for a rather spectacular collection of literary competition, passionate fandoms, and inevitable disagreements.
If you haven’t voted yet, Rebels, you still have time. Here are the dates to remember:
Once the opening round closes, the ten books receiving the most votes in each category will advance to the final. Readers will then have another opportunity to vote before the winners are announced on 3 December.
Naturally, I’ll be following the results here on Imperfect Rebel. I want to see how many of my choices survive the first round, how many make it to the finish line, and whether my literary judgement deserves a celebration or another enormous serving of Coke Zero.
My Goodreads Choice Awards 2026 Votes
For those of you curious about what happens inside the rather chaotic head of Lupe Farkas, here is my complete opening-round ballot.
| Category | My vote | Author |
|---|---|---|
| Fiction | Yesteryear | Caro Claire Burke |
| Historical Fiction | Royal Witch | Philippa Gregory |
| Mystery & Thriller | Dear Debbie | Freida McFadden |
| Romance | King of Gluttony | Ana Huang |
| Romantasy | A Court of Splintered Harmony | Sarah J. Maas |
| Fantasy | Dead Beat | Leigh Bardugo |
| Science Fiction | Time Travel for Beginners | Jaclyn Moriarty |
| Horror | Muñeca | Cynthia Gómez |
| Debut Novel | Yesteryear | Caro Claire Burke |
| Audiobook | Judge Stone | Viola Davis & James Patterson |
| Young Adult Fantasy & Sci-Fi | The Last King of Faerie | Cassandra Clare |
| Young Adult Fiction | The House of Gardenias | Isabel Cañas |
| Nonfiction | How to Be Okay When Nothing Is Okay | Jenny Lawson |
| Memoir | A Hymn to Life | Gisèle Pelicot |
| History & Biography | On Morrison | Namwali Serpell |
Fifteen votes, fourteen different books, and a rather impressive collection of women. With Freida McFadden, Sarah J. Maas, Gisèle Pelicot, and Namwali Serpell on the same ballot, my literary preferences apparently have considerably more range than my beverage preferences. Coke Zero, darling, you remain irreplaceable.
Freida McFadden vs Freida McFadden
Rebels, Dear Debbie is fucking amazing. There you have it: my extremely sophisticated literary opinion.
Freida McFadden finds herself in a rather enviable predicament this year. Both Dear Debbie and The Witch are nominated in Mystery & Thriller, whilst The Divorce is competing in the Audiobook category. Imagine becoming so successful that one of your biggest competitors for a literary award is yourself.
The interesting question is whether McFadden’s enormous readership will divide its votes between the two thrillers, potentially giving another author an advantage. Personally, my allegiance in this particular battle belongs to Debbie.
The Romantasy Queens Enter the Arena
Sarah J. Maas, Rebecca Yarros, Callie Hart, Rachel Gillig, Penn Cole, and several other formidable names are competing in what might be one of the most fiercely contested categories of this year’s awards. After everything we experienced surrounding the release of A Court of Splintered Harmony, including the leaks, the internet meltdowns, the midnight madness, and the endless speculation, did anybody seriously expect me to vote for something else?
The fascinating aspect of the Romantasy category is the sheer power of its readership. These authors have communities capable of generating extraordinary levels of engagement, and the competition between their fandoms could make the final round particularly entertaining. I suspect the internet will have plenty to say about whichever book eventually wins.
Yesteryear: Two of My Votes and an Anne Hathaway Movie
Caro Claire Burke received two of my votes, one for Fiction, and another for Debut Novel. Her debut, Yesteryear, has become one of this year’s most talked-about literary releases, exploring questions surrounding traditional womanhood, identity, and the carefully manufactured realities of social media. The novel is also nominated in Audiobook.
Hollywood was paying attention long before the novel reached readers. Amazon MGM Studios acquired the adaptation rights ahead of publication, with Anne Hathaway attached as its star, and as a producer. Screenwriter Hannah Friedman has been reported as attached to the adaptation.
A debut novelist, three Goodreads Choice Awards nominations, and Anne Hathaway bringing her work to the screen. Somewhere, thousands of authors are looking at their manuscripts, taking a deep breath, and wondering what exactly they need to sacrifice to the literary gods. I’ll keep you updated on the adaptation, Rebels. This one is firmly on my literary and cinematographic radar.
The Indie Authors Taking on the Publishing Giants
As an independent author, this is perhaps the section of the awards that excites me most. Among this year’s Romantasy nominees are at least two independently published titles, competing alongside some of the biggest commercial names in contemporary fiction.
Megan Shade — The Washwoman at the River’s End
Published through Shade Made Publishing LLC, this independently published gothic romantasy draws inspiration from Scottish folklore. Its nomination places Megan Shade in direct competition with authors whose books dominate international bestseller lists.
Scottish folklore, gothic fantasy, and an independent female author? Well, Rebels, somebody has just found another book for her reading list.
Edith Birde — Because I Killed Him
Edith Birde is the shared pen name of two sisters who have been writing together since their teenage years. Their independently published novel, released in May 2026, has secured a place in the same category as Sarah J. Maas and Rebecca Yarros.
Then there is Penn Cole, whose publishing journey demonstrates another possibility. Her official press kit lists traditional publishers for English print editions alongside self-published ebooks, making her a particularly interesting example of hybrid publishing.
For those following my Indie Author Experiment, these nominations are worth examining. Visibility remains one of the greatest challenges facing independent authors, and seeing independently published novels competing on this stage is enormously encouraging. These are examples, rather than a comprehensive audit of every nominee’s publishing history.
The Goodreads Controversy: Literary Excellence or a Popularity Contest?
Of course, what would a literary award be without a little controversy? Goodreads says its nominee selection draws on readers’ shelving, ratings, and review activity, with a minimum average rating of 3.50 at the beginning of voting. Audiobook nominations also use Audible data. The precise formula behind individual nominations, however, remains undisclosed.
This year, fantasy readers on Reddit have been questioning the nomination of Savannah Stephens’s Witch Queen Rising. One reader compared Goodreads shelving figures, pointing to several books with considerably more shelvings that had been omitted. Does that prove anything suspicious? Absolutely not. Shelving figures represent only one part of the available data. Nevertheless, greater transparency about how nominations are determined would certainly make these decisions easier to understand.
Romance readers have also questioned the representation of different subgenres, LGBTQ+ relationships, and authors from diverse backgrounds. For a genre with such an enormous and varied readership, twenty nomination slots can offer a remarkably narrow picture of what people are actually reading.
Perhaps the most peculiar aspect of the competition is that the published rules do not require readers to have finished the book they’re voting for. This raises a rather interesting question: are we voting for the best book of the year, the author we love most, or the book whose marketing campaign has been the most successful?
I enjoy the Goodreads Choice Awards enormously, but I also recognise their limitations. They offer a fascinating snapshot of contemporary reading culture, commercial success, fandoms, and the extraordinary influence of online book communities. Literary merit is considerably more complicated to measure.
Bram Stoker Has Entered the Competition
Something else made me laugh whilst examining this year’s nominees. Bram Stoker, who died in 1912, is competing in the Audiobook category alongside contemporary authors, thanks to a new audio edition of Dracula. J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is also nominated through a new audiobook edition.
Imagine spending years writing your novel, finally publishing it in 2026, and discovering that one of your competitors has been dead for 114 years. Apparently, even death cannot guarantee retirement from the publishing industry.
Could The Chosen Be Eligible for the 2027 Goodreads Choice Awards?
Rebels, allow me a little moment of authorial delusion. Whilst examining the official eligibility rules, I discovered that the publication window for next year’s awards runs from 11 November 2026 to 9 November 2027. My novel, The Chosen, which I wrote in forty-one days, was released on Friday, 13 November 2026.
Well, well, well. A date within the eligibility window obviously doesn’t guarantee a nomination. The rules apply to eligible English-language US publications, there are other requirements, and the competition for visibility is enormous. Nevertheless, as someone documenting the realities of independent publishing through a year-long experiment, I find the possibility rather entertaining.
Should we add this to our list of outrageously ambitious goals, Rebels? Why the hell not?
Now, Rebels, I Want Your Votes!
Have you already voted in the 2026 Goodreads Choice Awards? Which books received your votes? Are there any nominations you completely disagree with, any books you believe should have been included, or any authors you’re desperately hoping will win?
More importantly, who is competing with me in the literary prediction game? Tell me your choices in the comments, and we’ll see how many of us get it right when the winners are announced on 3 December.
Whilst we’re discussing Goodreads, why aren’t we friends yet? Come find me, follow my author page, send me a friend request, and let’s exchange book recommendations, reviews, and literary gossip. I love discovering what my Rebels are reading, and goodness knows my never-ending reading list could always accommodate another book. Or twenty.
I’ll be back on 24 November to discuss the finalists, the inevitable disappointments, and whatever fresh literary drama the internet provides.
One Last Thing, Rebels…
You might be wondering why I voted for Yesteryear twice, right? Well, I’ll be publishing my full editorial review later this week, and perhaps then you’ll understand why Caro Claire Burke earned two of my fifteen votes. In the meantime, you can read the review I wrote on Goodreads (the link is just below). Have you read it yet? I’m particularly curious to hear your thoughts on this one.
Until then, happy voting, Rebels!
With love from my wolfy heart,
Lupe Farkas
Your Imperfect Rebel
Join the Literary Rebellion
Vote in the 2026 awardsFollow my Goodreads author pageBecome my friend on Goodreads
Read my Yesteryear review on Goodreads
Buy The Chosen on Amazon · Buy Before October Ends on Amazon · Explore my books
More Literary Gossip from Imperfect Rebel
Sources and Further Reading
- Goodreads — official voting rules and eligibility
- Goodreads — 2026 awards announcement
- Parade — the opening-round nominations
- Vogue — Caro Claire Burke and the Yesteryear adaptation
- Deadline via Yahoo — Yesteryear screenwriter
- Reddit — Fantasy nomination discussion
- Reddit — Romance nomination discussion
- The StoryGraph — Megan Shade publishing editions
- Edith Birde — author information
- The StoryGraph — Because I Killed Him publishing editions
- Penn Cole — official publishing information
Never Miss a Little Literary Gossip
Subscribe to Imperfect Rebel for literary news, honest book reviews, publishing controversies, book-to-screen adaptations, and the unfiltered realities of independent authorship.

